10 Clues Your Choice of Gas Is Destroying Your Vehicle

June 23, 2025

Throughout my life (15 years of which I was a mechanic), I always had strong opinions about the fuel type I used for my car, plus many other strong opinions about brands. When I met my wife and realized she put the lowest grade gas in her vehicle, I questioned her, asking why. Now, granted, at the time she had a beat-up Chrysler PT Cruiser, but she didn’t really know anything about the quality of gas and the impact it can have on your vehicle. That said, here are 10 clues that the type of gas you’re using is secretly tearing your car apart.

Are You Filling Up with the Wrong Fuel Type?

1. Engine Knocking or Pinging Sounds

If you hear a knocking or pinging sound when accelerating, your car might be suffering from pre-ignition caused by the wrong fuel type. This happens when the air-fuel mixture combusts prematurely in the cylinder. High-compression engines are especially sensitive and usually require premium gas. Using regular fuel in these engines can cause long-term damage. That knocking sound is your engine begging for the right fuel.

2. Sluggish Acceleration

When your car doesn’t respond as quickly as it should when you hit the gas, low-quality fuel might be to blame. The wrong fuel type can affect how your engine burns gas, leading to weak performance. Engines that require higher-octane fuel need it to prevent misfires and power loss. If you’re using a cheaper alternative, you’re likely sacrificing horsepower. Over time, this can stress your engine’s internals and reduce its lifespan.

3. Lower Gas Mileage

Have you noticed you’re filling up more often than usual? Choosing the wrong fuel type can reduce your car’s fuel efficiency. The engine may not burn fuel cleanly or completely, forcing it to work harder. That means more trips to the pump and more strain on your engine. It’s a false economy—saving a few cents per gallon can cost you hundreds over the long run.

4. Rough Idling or Stalling

If your car idles unevenly, shakes, or even stalls while stopped, bad fuel may be the culprit. The wrong fuel type can cause incomplete combustion or clog fuel injectors. Ethanol-heavy gas blends in particular can cause problems in older engines not built to handle them. Your vehicle should run smoothly and quietly at idle—if it doesn’t, your fuel choice might be hurting more than helping. Ignoring these symptoms can lead to more expensive fuel system repairs.

5. Check Engine Light Keeps Coming On

The check engine light is your vehicle’s way of saying something’s wrong. Frequent issues triggered by the wrong fuel type can include misfires, fuel sensor problems, and emissions failures. Mechanics often trace these codes back to poor combustion or fuel quality. If your light keeps coming on shortly after you fill up, it’s worth reevaluating what you’re putting in the tank. It’s a small change that could make a big difference in repair costs.

6. Increased Exhaust Smoke

Notice thicker or darker exhaust fumes after you switch fuel brands or grades? The wrong fuel type may not burn completely in the combustion chamber. This leads to soot buildup, carbon residue, and dirty emissions. White, black, or blue smoke can all indicate a fuel-related issue. Your exhaust should be nearly invisible—if it’s not, your gas may be doing more harm than good.

7. Difficulty Starting the Engine

A hard start—especially in the morning or after refueling—can be a sign of bad gas. The wrong fuel type, particularly those with high ethanol content, can absorb moisture and cause fuel separation in the tank. This makes it harder for the engine to get the combustion it needs to start smoothly. Starting issues that seem to “go away” might actually be warning signs of bigger problems ahead. It’s not just an annoyance—it’s a fuel issue in disguise.

8. Strong Fuel Odor Around the Car

A persistent fuel smell—especially one that lingers even when the car is off—could indicate poor combustion. The wrong fuel type can leave unburnt fuel in the exhaust or fuel system, causing vapors to build up. Not only is this bad for your engine, but it also poses a fire hazard. If you’re constantly smelling gas, it’s time to question the last fuel you used. Poor fuel choices don’t just hurt performance—they risk your safety too.

9. Dirty or Clogged Spark Plugs

Mechanics often find gunked-up spark plugs when a car runs on improper fuel. The wrong fuel type can leave behind residue that clings to spark plug tips. This affects how the plugs fire and can lead to misfires, hesitation, or stalling. Routine inspections might reveal this damage early. If your spark plugs look dirtier than expected for your mileage, blame the gas, not the engine.

10. Your Car Manufacturer Recommends Premium—But You Ignore It

If your vehicle’s manual says to use premium gas, there’s a reason. Engineers designed your engine to operate under specific combustion pressures that only higher-octane fuel can provide. Using the wrong fuel type in these vehicles won’t just reduce performance—it could seriously shorten engine life. This is especially true for luxury or performance cars. Following manufacturer guidelines can save you thousands in long-term engine wear.

The Right Fuel Is More Than a Price Tag

It’s tempting to reach for the cheapest gas at the pump, but that decision could be slowly destroying your vehicle. The signs of using the wrong fuel type are often subtle at first but become costly over time. From damaged spark plugs to full engine failure, poor fuel choices ripple throughout your car’s most vital systems. Think beyond price per gallon and consider what your car actually needs. A little care now can save a lot of cash down the road.

Have you ever used the wrong fuel and paid the price? Share your experience—or your favorite gas station tips—in the comments and help other drivers avoid the same fate.

10 States Set On Banning Gas-Powered Vehicles In The Next 5 Years