The Little-Known Medicare Rule That Could Drain $7,200 a Year From You
Most people expect Medicare to lower their healthcare expenses in retirement, but a little-known rule could actually increase their Medicare costs by thousands each year. Known as IRMAA (Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount), this rule raises your premiums for Medicare Part B and Part D if your income exceeds certain limits. The increase isn’t small. In fact, it can add up to over $7,200 a year for higher-income retirees. The problem is that many people don’t find out about it until they’re hit with the bill. Understanding how this rule works is essential if you want to keep your retirement budget intact.
What IRMAA Actually Is
IRMAA is essentially a surcharge added to your Medicare premiums if your income is above a set threshold. It’s based on your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) from two years prior, meaning your 2023 Medicare costs are determined by your 2021 tax return. This delay catches many retirees off guard, especially if they had a high-income year before retirement. The surcharge applies separately to Part B (medical coverage) and Part D (prescription drug coverage). Even a slight income bump over the limit can trigger higher Medicare costs.
How It Can Reach $7,200 a Year
For the highest earners, IRMAA can add hundreds of dollars per month to both Part B and Part D premiums. As of 2024, the top IRMAA bracket can result in an extra $614 per month for Part B and $81 per month for Part D. Over a year, that’s $7,212 in additional Medicare costs on top of standard premiums. Even lower IRMAA brackets can add thousands annually, making it a major budget item for affected retirees. These costs are paid directly to Medicare, meaning you can’t shop around to avoid them.
Common Triggers for Higher Premiums
You don’t have to be a millionaire to get hit with IRMAA. One-time financial events, like selling property, converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, or receiving a large severance package, can temporarily raise your income. Because IRMAA uses your tax return from two years earlier, you might still get charged higher premiums even if your current income is much lower. This can be especially frustrating for new retirees who expected their Medicare costs to drop after leaving the workforce. Planning ahead can help you avoid these surprises.
The Appeals Process Many Don’t Know About
If your income has dropped significantly due to retirement, divorce, death of a spouse, or other qualifying life events, you may be able to appeal your IRMAA surcharge. Medicare has a formal process for this, but many retirees never take advantage of it. The key is filing Form SSA-44 with the Social Security Administration as soon as possible. Providing documentation (like recent tax returns or employer separation letters) can help get your Medicare costs reduced. Acting quickly is important because surcharges are typically billed monthly and won’t be refunded retroactively without an approved appeal.
Strategic Ways to Avoid the Surcharge
Avoiding IRMAA starts with managing your income in the years leading up to Medicare eligibility. Strategies like spacing out large capital gains, timing Roth conversions over multiple years, or increasing charitable donations can help keep your reported income below the thresholds. Some retirees choose to delay Social Security benefits to avoid stacking income sources in the same year. Working with a financial planner who understands Medicare costs can help you structure withdrawals and investments to minimize the risk of triggering IRMAA. Prevention is almost always cheaper than paying the surcharge.
The Role of Married Couples in Planning
Married couples need to be especially careful because IRMAA thresholds for joint filers are higher, but so are the potential costs if they’re exceeded. A single large withdrawal from a retirement account could push the household into a higher bracket for both spouses. This means the surcharge is effectively doubled, costing couples over $14,000 annually in extreme cases. Coordinating income strategies between spouses can make a big difference in managing Medicare costs. Joint planning ensures both partners benefit from lower premiums.
Why IRMAA Is Here to Stay
Some retirees hope IRMAA will disappear over time, but that’s unlikely. The surcharge was created to make higher-income beneficiaries pay a larger share of Medicare’s total costs. With Medicare’s overall expenses rising, lawmakers have little incentive to remove it, and thresholds aren’t adjusted for inflation in the same way tax brackets are. That means more retirees will fall into IRMAA brackets over time, even without earning more. Knowing this, it’s best to treat IRMAA as a permanent part of Medicare planning rather than a temporary inconvenience.
Turning Awareness Into Action
Understanding IRMAA is only half the battle; you need to act on the information. Reviewing your income two years before Medicare eligibility can reveal potential problem areas. If you’re already subject to IRMAA, explore the appeals process and make adjustments for future years. For those still a few years away from Medicare, now is the time to create a withdrawal and investment strategy that minimizes surcharges. Taking action early can keep thousands of dollars in your pocket each year.
Medicare Costs Don’t Have to Catch You Off Guard
The IRMAA surcharge may be a little-known Medicare rule, but its financial impact can be huge. By learning how it works, spotting common triggers, and planning ahead, you can avoid paying thousands more than necessary. Whether you’re approaching Medicare eligibility or already enrolled, keeping Medicare costs in check is one of the smartest moves you can make for a secure retirement. Awareness is your best defense against unnecessary expenses.
Have you ever been hit with an unexpected Medicare surcharge? How did you handle it? Share your story in the comments.
Read More
Is Medicare Prepared to Handle Your Partner’s Care—or Are You?
