8 Homeowners Sued Over Airbnb Rentals They Thought Were Legal

July 31, 2025

Renting out your home on Airbnb sounds simple. You list your place, set your price, and wait for guests. But for some homeowners, what seemed like an easy way to earn extra money turned into a legal nightmare. Cities and neighborhoods have rules about short-term rentals, and not everyone knows the details. Eight homeowners recently found themselves in court, facing lawsuits over Airbnb rentals they thought were legal. If you’re thinking about listing your home, or you already have, you need to know what happened to them—and how to avoid the same fate. Here’s what you can learn from their stories.

1. The Zoning Law Trap

One homeowner in a quiet suburb thought renting out her basement on Airbnb was fine. She checked her city’s website and didn’t see any clear ban. But her neighborhood had strict zoning laws that didn’t allow short-term rentals. A neighbor complained, and the city sued her. She faced thousands in fines and legal fees. Zoning laws can be hard to understand, but they matter. Always check both city and neighborhood rules before listing your property. Don’t assume that silence means approval.

2. The HOA Surprise

A couple in a gated community started renting their home on Airbnb to cover their mortgage. They didn’t realize their homeowners association (HOA) had rules against short-term rentals. After a few months, the HOA sent a cease-and-desist letter and then filed a lawsuit. The couple had to pay legal costs and stop renting. HOAs can have more power than you think. Read your HOA’s rules carefully. If you’re not sure, ask for written clarification. It’s better to be safe than sorry.

3. The License You Didn’t Know You Needed

A homeowner in a popular tourist city listed his condo on Airbnb. He didn’t know the town required a special short-term rental license. When city inspectors found out, they fined him and took him to court. He had to pay back taxes and penalties. Many cities now require permits or licenses for Airbnb rentals. Check your city’s website or call the local office. Getting a license may take time, but it’s cheaper than a lawsuit.

4. The Tax Bill Shock

One family rented out their lake house for extra income. They didn’t realize they needed to collect and pay local occupancy taxes. Months later, the city sued them for unpaid taxes and penalties. The bill was much higher than what they earned. Taxes on Airbnb rentals can be complicated. Some cities collect them automatically, but others don’t. Make sure you know your tax obligations.

5. The Neighbor Dispute

A homeowner in a quiet neighborhood started renting out rooms on Airbnb. Some neighbors didn’t like the extra cars and noise. They filed complaints, and the city sued the homeowner for violating nuisance laws. Even if your city allows Airbnb, neighbors can still cause problems. Talk to your neighbors before you start renting. Address their concerns and set clear house rules for guests. Good communication can prevent legal trouble.

6. The Insurance Gap

One landlord thought his regular homeowner’s insurance would cover Airbnb guests. When a guest caused major damage, the insurance company refused to pay. The landlord was sued by the guest and had to pay out of pocket. Standard insurance often doesn’t cover short-term rentals. You need special coverage for Airbnb. Check with your insurer and get the right policy. Airbnb offers some protection, but it may not be enough.

7. The Lease Violation

A renter listed his apartment on Airbnb without telling his landlord. The landlord found out and sued for breach of lease. The renter had to pay damages and was evicted. If you rent, check your lease before listing on Airbnb. Most leases ban subletting or short-term rentals. If you’re not sure, ask your landlord. Don’t risk eviction or a lawsuit.

8. The Retroactive Ban

One homeowner started renting on Airbnb when it was legal in her city. A year later, the city passed a new law banning short-term rentals in her area. She kept renting, thinking she was “grandfathered in.” The city sued her anyway. Laws can change, and you need to stay updated. Sign up for city alerts or check local news. If the law changes, stop renting until you know your rights.

Protecting Yourself in the Airbnb Maze

Short-term rentals can be a good way to earn money, but the rules are always changing. What happened to these eight homeowners could happen to anyone. Before you list your home, check every rule—city, neighborhood, HOA, and lease. Make sure you have the right insurance and pay all required taxes. Talk to your neighbors and keep up with new laws. Staying informed is the best way to avoid a lawsuit and keep your Airbnb rental legal.

Have you ever run into legal trouble with an Airbnb rental? Share your story or advice in the comments.

Why Your Homemade Cleaning Spray Might Be Destroying Your Air Quality