8 DIY Decks That Ended With Structural Collapse
A backyard deck project might seem like a fun weekend adventure, but when the structure goes wrong, disaster can strike. These DIY deck collapse stories show how common mistakes, poor design, or overlooked inspections led to sudden failures and serious injuries. You’ll learn what went wrong in each case, and get guidance on how to avoid committing similar errors. Understanding the risks helps you stay safe and potentially save lives. So, before grabbing that drill, read these eight cautionary tales.
1. Iowa Birthday Party Disaster
In Iowa, a DIY-built deck collapsed during a three-year-old’s birthday—about 20 people were gathered when it gave way. Footage shows the deck buckling mid-party, thankfully avoiding a full drop. Many guests fell and suffered injuries, though no fatalities were reported. This incident highlights key failure risks in DIY decks. Sadly, it became a clear example of a DIY deck collapse gone wrong.
2. Clinton, Maryland Family Celebration Gone Wrong
Four people were hospitalized after a DIY wood deck collapsed in Clinton, Maryland, during a family gathering. The structure gave way unexpectedly under load, sending several adults to the hospital with non-life-threatening injuries. Witnesses reported that the collapse occurred in a residential neighborhood. It underscores how common household events can trigger a DIY deck failure. This case emphasizes the unpredictability of a DIY deck collapse.
3. Boston Dorchester Multi-Story Porch Failure
In Boston’s Dorchester, a third-floor DIY porch collapsed under a small crowd at a cookout. Nine people were injured, one critically, as the structure gave way toward the backyard. Surveillance video revealed the porch cracked before giving way, and heavy items slid off, causing additional harm. This shows how DIY decks—especially elevated ones—can fail catastrophically. A sobering example of high-risk DIY deck collapse.
4. Illinois Home Inspectors’ Nightmare
In Illinois, a newly built deck—noted by inspectors as lacking lag bolts and improperly attached to the house—collapsed during a move-in party. Eight people were on it when it fell, causing moderate injuries. The home inspection had flagged safety concerns but advised only monitoring. That misstep contributed to the failure under load. A cautionary lesson for DIYers and inspectors alike about the dangers of underbolting: a classic DIY deck collapse scenario.
5. Bella Vista Deck Failure
In Bella Vista, Arkansas, a deck built about 12–15 feet above ground collapsed under weight during use. Multiple injuries were reported, and the city traced the failure to overloading and structural inadequacies. The DIY nature of the deck likely contributed to poor engineering and insufficient support. This event shows how height amplifies the consequences of DIY mistakes. It stands out as a serious DIY deck collapse warning.
6. Pennsylvania Poolside Collapse
In Sheraden, Pennsylvania, a backyard deck by a pool collapsed during a family swim—one adult and three children were injured. Although none were seriously hurt, they were trapped under debris until rescued. The incident was traced back to weak joists and unsupported spans. It’s a reminder: DIY decks near water and pools still require proper structural support. A quieter but poignant example of DIY deck collapse risk.
7. Overcrowded Canadian Deck Under Photo Shoot
In Nova Scotia, a large group of high school students clustered at the edge of a DIY deck for a photo, and it collapsed. About 40 students were thrown 10–15 feet to the ground; 12 were hospitalized. Though common spaces failed under extreme load, inadequate joist spacing and undersized materials were key causes. This incident illustrates how assumptions about deck capacity can lead to rapid failure. It’s another powerful case of DIY deck collapse.
8. Chicago Balcony Collapse—Design and Load Failures
The 2003 Chicago balcony collapse killed 13 people and injured 57 during a party, triggered by poor deck connections, undersized support, and overcrowding. Though not strictly DIY, the same construction errors replicate on home-built decks: inadequate fasteners, overreach, and improper anchoring. Investigators cited undersized screws, lack of proper ledger attachment, and no permit for the deck as causes. This historic tragedy underscores DIY risks when codes and design are ignored. A tragic counterpart to home DIY deck failures.
How to Avoid Your Own DIY Deck Collapse Nightmare
If you’re building or maintaining a deck yourself, prioritize safety at every step. Use proper ledger attachment techniques—lag or through bolts, flashed to prevent rot—and never rely on nails alone. Follow your local building codes: size joists and beams for weight loads and seasons, especially for elevated decks. Inspect decks annually for rot, rust, loose fasteners, or shifting. When in doubt, consult an engineer or professional builder—prevention beats reconstruction any time in a DIY deck collapse scenario.
Have you ever rebuilt or repaired a deck—or known someone whose deck failed? What safety mistakes or lessons did you learn? Share your experiences or tips in the comments!
Read More
