10 Homeowners Who Got Sued Over Fence Lines and Shed Placement
Fences and sheds seem simple. You put them up, and they mark your space. But for many homeowners, these structures have led to lawsuits, stress, and big bills. Fence lines and shed placement can spark arguments with neighbors, sometimes ending up in court. These disputes can cost time, money, and even friendships if you own a home or plan to, knowing what can go wrong with fence lines and shed placement matters. Here are ten real situations where homeowners got sued, and what you can learn from them.
1. The Six-Inch Fence Dispute
A homeowner in Texas built a fence that was just six inches over the property line. The neighbor noticed and filed a lawsuit. The court ordered the fence to be moved, and the homeowner paid for the legal fees and the new fence. This case shows how even a small mistake can lead to big problems. Always check your property lines before building anything.
2. The Shed That Blocked the View
In California, a homeowner put up a large shed right next to the neighbor’s yard. The neighbor claimed the shed blocked sunlight and ruined their view. The case went to court, and the judge ordered the shed to be moved. The homeowner had to pay damages. Before you build a shed, think about how it affects your neighbors. Sometimes, a quick conversation can prevent a lawsuit.
3. The Fence on Public Land
A family in Florida built a fence that extended onto public land. The city sued them, demanding that the fence be removed. The family lost the case and had to pay a fine. This story is a reminder to check city maps and zoning rules before building. Public land is off-limits, even if it looks like part of your yard.
4. The Disappearing Boundary Markers
In New York, two neighbors disagreed about where the property line was. One homeowner removed old boundary markers and put up a new fence. The other sued, claiming the fence was on their land. The court sided with the neighbor who lost land. The lesson: never move or remove boundary markers without a survey. It’s worth the cost to avoid a lawsuit.
5. The HOA Shed Ban
A homeowner in a planned community put up a shed without checking the homeowners association (HOA) rules. The HOA sued, saying sheds were not allowed. The homeowner had to remove the shed and pay a fine. Always read your HOA rules before building. HOAs can and do sue over shed placement and fence lines.
6. The Fence That Blocked Access
In Illinois, a homeowner built a fence that blocked a shared driveway. The neighbor sued for access. The court ordered the fence to be moved and the homeowner to pay damages. Shared spaces can be tricky. If you share a driveway or path, talk to your neighbor before building anything. Written agreements help avoid confusion.
7. The Shed on the Easement
A homeowner in Georgia put a shed on a utility easement. The utility company sued and won. The shed had to be removed, and the homeowner paid for the removal. Easements are areas where others have legal rights, such as for utilities or drainage. Always check your deed and local records for easements before building.
8. The Fence That Sparked a Feud
In Ohio, a new fence went up right on the property line. The neighbor claimed it was a few inches over and sued. The case dragged on for years, costing both sides thousands. In the end, the fence was moved, and both neighbors were left with legal bills. This case shows how fence-line disputes can escalate. Mediation is often less expensive and faster than going to court.
9. The Historic District Shed
A homeowner in Massachusetts built a shed in a historic district without a permit. The city sued, saying the shed violated local rules. The homeowner had to remove the shed and pay a fine. Historic districts have strict rules about what you can build. Always check with your city or county before adding a shed or fence.
10. The Fence That Ignored Setbacks
In Arizona, a homeowner built a fence right up to the edge of the property. Local rules required a setback of three feet. The city sued, and the homeowner had to move the fence. Setback rules exist in many places. They keep fences and sheds from being too close to roads or neighbors. Check your local codes before building.
What These Lawsuits Teach Homeowners
Fence line and shed placement lawsuits are more common than you might think. They can happen to anyone, even if you think you’re careful. The main lesson is to do your homework before building. Always check your property lines, local rules, and HOA guidelines. Talk to your neighbors. Get permits when needed. A little planning can save you from a costly lawsuit. If you’re unsure, hire a surveyor or ask your city for help. It’s better to spend a little now than a lot later.
Have you ever had a dispute with a neighbor over a fence or shed? Share your story or advice in the comments.
Read More
Why Your Homemade Cleaning Spray Might Be Destroying Your Air Quality
