Which Cities Have the Most Police Complaints Per Capita?
When you look at a statistic like police complaints per capita, it can tell you a lot about the area. There may be issues with trusting the police in the city. Training could be another problem, or it could just be the culture in policing in that city. Whatever the case may be, these numbers can help citizens and lawmakers better understand where reforms might be needed in the system. These four cities have the highest number of complaints per capita, but what does it tell us about policing across the United States?
1. San Francisco: Big Oversight, Even Bigger Complaints
San Francisco consistently shows one of the highest rates of police complaints per resident—despite being smaller than NYC or LA. Its proactive Office of Citizen Complaints pushes transparency and encourages more reports than many other cities. A high rate of complaints doesn’t necessarily mean more misconduct—it could mean a more engaged public and stronger reporting systems . Still, elevated complaint frequencies can indicate systemic tensions between police and civilians. For residents and visitors alike, it’s a reminder to stay aware and vigilant.
2. Chicago: Disparities Spark Complaints
Chicago frequently appears in studies on policing disparities, and that includes complaints. Analysis shows Black residents are far more likely to face police attention and file misconduct complaints than white residents. This demographic tension drives up the city’s police complaints per capita, highlighting a city grappling with equity issues. Despite efforts at reform, Chicago’s complaint volume remains high—often tied to use-of-force and biased policing allegations. Recognizing these patterns is essential for local reforms and rebuilding public trust.
3. Albuquerque: A Department Under Scrutiny
Albuquerque’s police department has been under a consent decree after repeated allegations of brutality. In 2016 alone, its civilian oversight agency recorded 125 complaints in six months—a high tally for a city of its size. Investigators described the APD as one of the most violently prone in the country. Those numbers directly drive Albuquerque’s elevated police complaints per capita, reflecting both real issues and increased reporting. The ongoing oversight and reforms indicate the seriousness—but also the momentum—for change.
4. Brookside, AL: Small Town, Big Problem
Brookside, Alabama, is a tiny town of just over 1,200 people, but it has seen massive policing activity in recent years. They had nine officers in 2020—about one for every 144 residents. That same year, they towed 789 vehicles and wrote numerous tickets—generating high complaint volumes for a small population. Lawsuits now allege fabricated charges, showing how overt policing inflates complaints per capita and harms local trust. It’s a warning that big police presence doesn’t always mean better policing.
Why These Numbers Shine a Light on Accountability
High police complaints per capita can mean different things—but often it signals conflict or lack of trust. Cities with strong civilian oversight or transparent reporting tend to show more complaints—not necessarily worse police behavior. But when complaint rates are high AND misconduct is proven, it points to deep problems in training or culture. Only about 1 in 7 complaints nationwide are sustained, so complaint volume alone doesn’t equal accountability. What matters is whether those complaints lead to meaningful policy changes and improved policing.
How Communities Can Respond and Improve
- Encourage civilian oversight boards with subpoena powers and public reporting—San Francisco and Albuquerque show this matters.
- Improve complaint transparency so residents feel heard and understood.
- Track complaint data per capita, not just raw numbers—smaller cities like Brookside can see big spikes.
- Push for independent investigations when complaints include use of force or racial bias.
- Educate the public on how to file complaints and on typical police conduct expectations.
By combining data, oversight, and community education, cities can turn high complaint rates into catalysts for positive change.
Bottom Line on Police and Public Trust
In cities like San Francisco, Chicago, Albuquerque—and even Brookside—the high police complaints per capita point to ongoing stress points between communities and law enforcement. These complaints aren’t just numbers—they’re signals that something needs reform, transparency, or accountability. The good news? Some cities are already acting, and boosting oversight shows promise. If you care about safe, fair policing, it’s worth watching complaint patterns in your city—and demanding improvements. That’s how change begins.
High complaint levels spark important questions: do they reflect proactive reporting, systemic problems—or both? What’s happening in your city? Are oversight boards working—or lacking teeth? Your experiences and insights matter in this national conversation.
Read More
5 U.S. States Where Police Can Confiscate Firearms Without Warning
Police Departments Are Secretly Using These Civilian Vehicles for Surveillance
