10 Renovation Trends That Buyers Are Avoiding Like the Plague

September 1, 2025

Home renovations can boost your property’s value or help it stand out in a crowded market. But not every trend is a winner. Some choices might seem stylish now, but make buyers cringe later. Understanding which renovation trends buyers are avoiding like the plague is key if you want a quick sale and a solid return on investment. Ignoring these preferences could mean your home sits on the market longer or fetches a lower price. Knowing what to skip helps you spend your renovation dollars wisely.

1. Overly Personalized Themes

It’s tempting to design a home that reflects your personality, but buyers don’t want to feel like they’re stepping into someone else’s fantasy. Bold wallpaper, unusual color palettes, or themed rooms (think pirate dens or jungle bathrooms) often require extra work to undo. When buyers see spaces that scream “custom,” they think of time and money spent on renovation trends they’ll need to reverse.

2. Open Shelving Instead of Cabinets

Open shelving looks great in magazines, but in real life, it’s less practical. Buyers often see it as a dust trap and a hassle to keep organized. Most people prefer the concealed storage that traditional cabinets offer. Renovation trends like open shelving can make kitchens feel less functional and more cluttered, turning off potential buyers who want low-maintenance solutions.

3. Converted Garages

Converting a garage into living space might seem like a smart way to add square footage, but it can backfire. Many buyers value a secure, weatherproof place for their cars and storage. Losing the garage can be a dealbreaker, especially in regions with harsh weather or limited street parking. If you’re weighing this renovation trend, consider your future buyers’ needs first.

4. Luxury Bathrooms With Oversized Tubs

While a spa bathroom sounds appealing, huge soaking tubs are losing their luster. They take up a lot of space and aren’t always practical for families or older buyers. Many people prefer a large, walk-in shower over a bathtub they’ll rarely use. When it comes to renovation trends, less is often more in the bathroom.

5. Removing Closets for More Space

Storage is a top priority for today’s homebuyers. Knocking out closets to expand bedrooms or living areas might make a room feel bigger, but it also makes the home less functional. Buyers see a lack of closets as a major inconvenience. This renovation trend can actually decrease your home’s appeal and value.

6. Ultra-Modern Fixtures and Finishes

Sleek, modern fixtures might look impressive now, but trends change fast. Buyers are wary of homes loaded with ultra-modern lighting, faucets, or appliances that could look dated in a few years. Sticking with classic, neutral fixtures has broader appeal and is more likely to withstand changing tastes in renovation trends.

7. Wall-to-Wall Carpeting

Carpet used to be a standard pick, but most buyers now prefer hardwood or luxury vinyl floors. Wall-to-wall carpeting can trap odors, stains, and allergens. It’s also seen as outdated, especially in living rooms and bedrooms. This is one renovation trend that’s best left in the past if you want to attract today’s buyers.

8. Removing Bathtubs Entirely

While some buyers love a big shower, many still want at least one bathtub—especially families with young children. Removing all tubs in favor of showers can shrink your pool of potential buyers. If you’re updating a bathroom, keep at least one tub to appeal to a wider audience and avoid this renovation trend pitfall.

9. High-Maintenance Landscaping

Elaborate gardens, water features, and specialty plants may look beautiful, but most buyers see them as extra work. People want outdoor spaces that are easy to care for. High-maintenance landscaping is a renovation trend that can make your home feel like a chore, not a retreat. Simple, tidy yards are much more appealing to the average buyer.

10. Bold Tile Choices

Colorful or patterned tile can make a statement, but it’s a risky move. Tastes vary, and what you love might turn off someone else. Bold tiles are also expensive and difficult to replace, making buyers hesitate. If you want to use trendy tile, limit it to small, easy-to-change areas like backsplashes instead of floors or showers.

Making Smart Choices With Renovation Trends

When planning updates, keep in mind which renovation trends buyers are avoiding like the plague. Focus on changes that add value and have broad appeal. Neutral colors, classic fixtures, and practical features usually win out over bold or highly personal choices. If you’re unsure, talk with a local real estate agent or look at recent sales in your area to see what’s working. You’ll get better results—and fewer regrets—by skipping trends that don’t stand the test of time.

What renovation trends have you seen buyers avoid in your area? Share your experiences in the comments below!