10 Car Repairs You Should Never Trust a Dealership With
When your car needs attention, your first instinct might be to head straight to the dealership. After all, they sold you the car, so they must be the experts, right? Not so fast. While dealerships have access to factory parts and brand-specific expertise, they’re also known for inflated prices, upselling, and long wait times. There are some repairs where you’re simply better off going with an independent mechanic, and here are ten you should definitely avoid trusting to the dealership.
1. Brake Pad Replacements
You don’t need a dealership to tell you your brake pads are worn down. This is a basic repair, and dealerships often charge double or even triple what a local shop would. The parts themselves are inexpensive, and a qualified mechanic can swap them out in under an hour. Dealership car repair shops love to add unnecessary rotor resurfacing or upsell you on “premium” pads that you don’t really need. Stick with a local ASE-certified mechanic to save serious cash.
2. Oil Changes
Believe it or not, oil changes are one of the most overpriced services at a dealership. This routine job should cost $40–$70 at most for conventional oil, yet some dealerships will quote you upwards of $150, especially for synthetic blends. Worse, they’ll often push unnecessary “inspections” to inflate the final cost. Independent oil shops or chain service centers can do the job just as well, often faster, and with far less hassle. You’re literally paying more for the logo on the invoice.
3. Battery Replacement
Unless your vehicle requires a special type of battery (which is rare), you do not need to pay dealership prices. A simple battery swap at a dealership could cost you $300 or more, while a trusted local shop or auto parts store can do it for half that. Many even test and install for free when you buy the battery from them. Dealership car repair teams might also charge diagnostic fees before even confirming the battery is the issue. Save your time and money on this one.
4. Tire Services and Replacements
Dealerships are notoriously expensive when it comes to tires. They often push specific brands and charge hefty installation fees that aren’t competitive with tire shops or wholesale clubs. Local tire shops typically offer better deals, including lifetime rotation or balancing, and offer rebates that dealerships don’t advertise. You also have more choices in brand and performance level. There’s no reason to pay dealership markups on something so easily handled elsewhere.
5. Windshield Wiper Replacement
This is a five-minute fix that you can do yourself, or have done at most auto stores for free with a purchase. Yet many dealerships charge $30–$50 or more for this basic task. They might convince you to replace all your wipers even if just one is worn, padding your final bill. Don’t fall for it. You’ll get the same result for a fraction of the price at any auto store.
6. Headlight or Taillight Bulb Replacement
Like wipers, bulbs are cheap and easy to replace. Most modern vehicles make it simple to swap a burnt-out bulb, yet dealerships can charge $100 or more for labor alone. They’ll also often push “full light inspections” and charge for bulbs that don’t even need replacing. A local shop can handle it for half the price—or you can do it yourself with a YouTube tutorial and a $10 bulb.
7. Air Filter Replacement
Cabin and engine air filters are another upsell favorite at dealerships. They’ll show you a slightly dirty filter and charge $50–$80 for something that costs $10–$20 and takes less than 10 minutes to change. This is one of the simplest maintenance tasks you can do yourself, or have done by a local shop during a routine service. Don’t fall for the dealership’s high-margin suggestion.
8. Coolant Flushes
Coolant flushes are important—but not when they’re unnecessarily frequent or overpriced. Dealership car repair services often recommend this service more often than needed and charge a premium to perform it. Many local shops can do it properly for significantly less. Check your owner’s manual for the real interval recommendation before agreeing to anything. Then get a second opinion elsewhere.
9. Diagnostic Scans
That “Check Engine” light doesn’t mean you owe the dealership $150 just to tell you what’s wrong. Most auto parts stores will scan your codes for free and give you a printout of the issue. While dealerships might have brand-specific scanners, they often use generic ones anyway and charge you top dollar for them. Save their diagnostics for complicated issues only. For minor ones, go local or DIY first.
10. Non-Warranty Work After Warranty Expires
Once your warranty ends, the dealership has no pricing advantage, but often keeps charging premium prices. Whether it’s a starter, alternator, or ignition coil, you can get high-quality work from reputable independent mechanics for much less. Don’t let dealership branding fool you into thinking they’re your only option. Post-warranty, you owe them nothing, and you’ll likely get better customer service elsewhere, too.
Know When to Walk—And When to Drive to a Local Shop
Dealerships have their place, especially for warranty work or complex brand-specific recalls. But for many routine repairs and maintenance, their pricing and tactics don’t make sense for everyday drivers. Being loyal to your vehicle doesn’t mean being loyal to overpriced services. A trustworthy local mechanic can save you hundreds (or even thousands) over the lifetime of your car. And in most cases, you’ll get more honest, personalized service in return.
Have you ever been overcharged by a dealership or saved money by going local? Share your experience in the comments! We want to hear your car care wins (and horror stories).
Read More
10 Signs Your Car Is About to Need a Major Repair
10 Things Your Mechanic Wishes You Knew Before Doing DIY Repairs
Drew Blankenship is a former Porsche technician who writes and develops content full-time. He lives in North Carolina, where he enjoys spending time with his wife and two children. While Drew no longer gets his hands dirty modifying Porsches, he still loves motorsport and avidly watches Formula 1.