Why Car Insurance Claims Quietly Increase If You Own These Vehicles

Car insurance claims can be a headache, especially when you notice your premiums inching up without a clear reason. But did you know that the type of vehicle you drive has a significant impact on how often claims are filed—and how much you pay? Insurance companies track claims data closely, and certain vehicles tend to be involved in more claims than others. This can result in higher costs for owners, even if you’re a safe driver. Understanding which vehicles attract more claims can help you make smarter decisions and possibly save money on your car insurance. Below, we’ll break down which types of vehicles often lead to increased car insurance claims and why that happens.
1. Sports Cars
Sports cars frequently top the list when it comes to increased car insurance claims. Their powerful engines and sleek designs make them appealing to drivers who enjoy speed. Unfortunately, that same appeal often leads to riskier driving behaviors, resulting in more accidents and, consequently, more claims. Car insurance companies notice these trends and adjust rates accordingly. If you own a sports car, you might find yourself paying more even if you drive responsibly, simply because claims for this type of vehicle are higher across the board.
Another factor is the cost of repairs. Sports cars often use specialized parts that are more expensive to replace or fix. This drives up the average claim amount, further influencing insurance premiums. If you’re considering a sports car, factor in not just the sticker price, but also the ongoing insurance costs tied to frequent car insurance claims.
2. Luxury Vehicles
Owning a luxury vehicle like a BMW, Mercedes-Benz, or Lexus might feel rewarding, but these cars are also linked to higher car insurance claims. Luxury vehicles are attractive targets for theft, which leads to more comprehensive claims. They also come with advanced features that can be costly to repair or replace after an accident, making every claim more expensive for insurers.
Additionally, luxury cars are often involved in minor accidents simply because their high-end finishes and tech features are more sensitive to damage. Even a small fender bender can result in a large claim. Insurers factor this into their pricing, so luxury car owners often see higher premiums, reflecting the increased risk of car insurance claims.
3. Pickup Trucks
Pickup trucks are popular for their versatility and utility, but they also see a steady stream of car insurance claims. Many pickups are used for work, hauling, and towing, which puts them in situations where accidents are more likely to occur. The sheer size and weight of pickup trucks can lead to more significant damage when accidents happen, driving up claim costs.
Pickup trucks are also at risk for theft, especially models that are in high demand for their parts. This combination of accident risk and theft potential means that owning a pickup truck can quietly increase your chances of filing a car insurance claim—and paying more for coverage.
4. Compact and Subcompact Cars
It might seem surprising, but compact and subcompact cars often have a higher rate of car insurance claims. These smaller vehicles are popular with new drivers and commuters, both groups that statistically get into more accidents. While repair costs might be lower than those for luxury or sports cars, the frequency of claims is what matters most to insurers.
Compact cars can also be more vulnerable in collisions, leading to higher injury claims. If you’re driving a small car, be aware that your choice may impact your insurance rates due to the higher likelihood of claims, even if the individual claim amounts are smaller.
5. Electric Vehicles
Electric vehicles (EVs) are on the rise, but they come with unique insurance challenges. The components in EVs—like batteries—are expensive to replace, and not all repair shops are equipped to handle these vehicles. As a result, when EVs are involved in accidents, the cost of car insurance claims can be much higher than for traditional vehicles.
Another issue is that EVs are often targeted for certain types of theft, such as stealing charging cables or even the entire vehicle. As more EVs hit the road, insurers are closely tracking car insurance claims to adjust premiums and coverage options. If you own or are considering an EV, it’s important to factor in these potential hidden costs.
How Your Vehicle Choice Affects Your Car Insurance Claims
Your choice of vehicle plays a bigger role in your insurance costs than you might think. Car insurance claims are not just about how you drive, but also about the trends insurance companies see with specific models. If your car is linked to higher accident rates, theft, or costly repairs, your premiums will reflect that risk—even if you have a clean driving record.
Before buying a new or used car, take the time to research its claims history. This extra step could save you money and help you avoid unexpected increases in your car insurance costs down the road.
Have you noticed your car insurance claims or premiums rising because of the type of vehicle you own? Share your experience in the comments below!
What to Read Next…
- Why Insurance Rates Spike For Drivers Of Specific Brands And Its Not Just Risk
- Auto Insurance Companies Are Quietly Buying Totaled Cars And Reselling Them
- 8 Auto Insurance Policies That Deny The Most Claims
- 8 Car Mods That Will Ruin Your Insurance Rates
- 7 Car Insurance Discounts That Quietly Disappeared
