8 Nutrition Myths That Are Still Being Taught in Medical School
Nutrition education in medical schools has come a long way, but not far enough. Despite mountains of new research, many myths that should have been retired decades ago still find their way into lectures, textbooks, and board exam prep. These outdated ideas shape how new doctors counsel patients, which can have real consequences for public health.
Some myths stick around because they are simple, easy to memorize, and convenient to repeat. Others persist because changing an entrenched curriculum is far more difficult than simply repeating what has always been taught.
1. Calories Are All That Matter for Weight Loss
Future doctors still often hear that weight loss is nothing more than “calories in versus calories out.” This old chestnut ignores the impact of food quality, hormonal responses, and individual metabolism. Highly processed foods can create cycles of hunger and insulin spikes that sabotage even the most disciplined calorie counters. Meanwhile, whole foods with fiber and healthy fats can satisfy longer and support better metabolic health. Teaching patients to count calories without teaching them about food quality does more harm than good.
2. Low-Fat Diets Are the Key to Heart Health
Decades ago, fat became public enemy number one in the fight against heart disease. This belief is so ingrained that medical students still hear that cutting fat is the best way to protect the heart. However, research now shows that healthy fats, such as those from avocados, nuts, and olive oil, are beneficial for cardiovascular health. It is refined carbohydrates and added sugars that often do the real damage. The persistence of this myth means patients may be steered away from healthy fats they should be eating more of.
3. All Cholesterol Is Bad
Cholesterol remains one of the most misunderstood elements of nutrition taught in medical school. Many still learn that all cholesterol is harmful and must be lowered at all costs. In reality, cholesterol is vital for hormone production, cell membrane integrity, and brain function. The problem arises with oxidized LDL particles and chronic inflammation, not cholesterol alone. Teaching nuanced understanding rather than blanket fear could help millions manage their heart health more effectively.
4. Salt Is Always Dangerous
For decades, salt has been demonized as the main culprit behind high blood pressure and heart disease. While excessive salt intake can be harmful for certain people, especially those with salt-sensitive hypertension, the issue is more complex. Many people with normal kidney function can handle moderate salt intake without trouble. The real danger often lies in processed foods that combine excess sodium with low potassium and high sugar. Blanket advice to cut salt can overlook individual needs and broader dietary patterns.
5. Red Meat Should Be Avoided Entirely
Medical students are often taught that red meat is uniformly bad for health, increasing risks of cancer and heart disease. However, emerging research suggests that context matters: the source and preparation of meat make a difference. Grass-fed, minimally processed red meat can be part of a balanced diet when consumed in moderation. The greater threat comes from processed meats loaded with preservatives and additives. Oversimplified messages about red meat can misguide patients away from nutrient-rich foods they might actually benefit from.
6. Supplements Are Mostly Useless
Future physicians still encounter the idea that vitamin and mineral supplements are unnecessary for most people. This myth ignores the reality that modern diets and lifestyles often leave gaps that supplements can safely fill. Soil depletion, food processing, and poor eating habits contribute to widespread deficiencies in nutrients like vitamin D, magnesium, and omega-3s. While supplements should never replace real food, dismissing them outright does patients no favors. A balanced message would teach new doctors when supplementation makes sense.
7. Dairy Is Essential for Strong Bones
Generations of doctors have been told that milk and dairy are the best insurance for bone health. Calcium is important, but this oversimplified message overlooks other critical factors like vitamin D, magnesium, weight-bearing exercise, and overall diet quality. Populations with low dairy intake often have strong bones and lower osteoporosis rates due to diverse diets and active lifestyles. Lactose intolerance is also common worldwide, making dairy a poor universal prescription. Clinging to the dairy myth can prevent doctors from giving better, individualized guidance.
8. Nutrition Basics Can Be Learned Later
One of the most damaging myths is that nutrition is too basic to prioritize in medical school. The idea that doctors can pick up nutritional counseling skills on the job often results in rushed, outdated advice. Meanwhile, chronic diseases like obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease continue to rise, driven by poor nutrition. Patients often expect doctors to be trusted guides on what to eat and what to avoid. Medical schools that sideline nutrition education fail to prepare future physicians for the frontlines of preventive care.
It’s Time to Challenge Outdated Nutrition Dogma
Nutrition education should never stand still, especially when patient health depends on it. Outdated myths that linger in medical schools shape entire generations of physicians and the advice they pass on. Shedding these myths requires open minds, better research literacy, and a willingness to rewrite decades of conventional wisdom.
Medical schools must take responsibility for updating what they teach about food and health. Share thoughts or experiences below—what other nutrition myths deserve to be retired for good?
Read More
6 Reasons Men Avoid Doctor Visits—and What It’s Costing Them
